Justice As A Legal Value: Cultural And Philosophical Analysis


  • Maria Stanislavovna Matantseva



Palabras clave:

justice, freedom, law, empathy, socio-cultural identity, social value, communication


The article seeks to conduct a cultural and philosophical analysis of the notion of justice as a legal value.  The authors of this work criticize the attempts to define justice as a universal value and suggest seeking the nature of justice in the field of socio-cultural identification and communication.

Representations about justice are the result of reflective activities, based on a logical comparison operation. The value systems of different people are considered as the compared objects. The sense of justice is due to the ability of people to empathy - the ability to project themselves into the place of another person.  An important condition for empathy is that people whose actions are judged in terms of justice should be related to the same sociocultural community.  Social communication is seen as a means of objectification individual perceptions of justice, turning them into social value.

Based on the findings, the social significance of the jury trial is disclosed, the conditions for the fairness of laws and judgments are determined.


Aristotle. Nicomachean Ethics / Transl. N. Braginskaya. Moscow, 1997.

Berdyaev N.A. The Kingdom of Spirit and the Kingdom of Caesar. Moscow, 2003.

Bogdanov D.E. Justice as the main principle of civil liability in Russian and foreign law: a doctoral dissertation. Moscow, 2014.

Voplenko N.N. Freedom and justice: the laws of their interaction. Bulletin of Volgograd State University. Series 5. Jurisprudence, 2012; 1. P. 9.

Hegel G.W.F. The Philosophy of Law. Moscow, 1990.

Derrida J. Force de loi: le «fondement mystique de l'autorité». Paris: Galilee, 1994.

Dubber M.D. The sense of justice: empathy in law and punishment. New York: NYU Press, 2006.

Kant I. Critique of Pure Reason. Saint Petersburg, 2005.

Nanaeva B.B. Freedom as a tribal characteristic of the ethnos self-consciousness and the phenomenon of culture. Theory and practice of social development, 2010; 2. P. 37-41.

Nersesyants V.S. The Philosophy of Law. 2 ed., reworked and additional. Moscow, 2006.

Plato. The Republic / trans. from Ancient Greek A.N. Egunova. Moscow, 2016.

Rawls J. Theory of Justice. (revised edition). Cambridge, Massachusetts: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1999.

Tarde G. Penal Philosophy. Introduction Beirne P. Transaction Publishers, 2001.

Tlehatuk S.A. Legal identity as an object of socio-cultural analysis. Theory and practice of social development, 2016; 11.

Frank S.L. God is with us. Moscow, 2003.



Cómo citar

Stanislavovna Matantseva, M. (2019). Justice As A Legal Value: Cultural And Philosophical Analysis. Revista San Gregorio, (36). https://doi.org/10.36097/rsan.v0i36.1209